Complaint > Tbilisi Railway Bypass 4

Eligibility: Eligibility Assessment Report

...REQUEST NUMBER: 2011/04 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY On 16 March 2011 the PCM Officer received a complaint (“Complaint”) from Mrs Nino Saginashvili (“Complainant”), a resident of Avchala settlement, one of the areas on the proposed bypass route on Tbilisi Railway Bypass Project (“Project)”. The Complaint was registered on 24 March 2011 and the PCM Expert Dr Walter Leal was appointed to act as Eligibility Assessor, together with the PCM Officer. The Complainant re...

Complaint > Altain Khuder debt & equity

Monitoring: Compliance Review Monitoring Report II

...request that this item is closed. operations, EBRD’s monitoring and reporting requirements would be re-established and an assessment of current status against the ESAP commitments would need to be undertaken. Under such a development, EBRD would promptly request and implement monitoring events that would likely 5 include a s...

Complaint > Dariali HPP

Filing: Complaint (English)

...President of Georgia, Mikheil Saakashvili, calling for suspension of large and other hydro-power development projects, including Dariali HPP, that pose a serious threat to the environment and livelihoods; December 21, 2011; See In Georgian: http://www.greenalt.org/webmill/data/file/Letter_to_president_HPP_geo.pdf In English: http://www.greenalt.org/webmill/data/file/Letter_to_president_HPPs_ENG.pdf 5. Green Alternative issued and disseminated the fact sheet “How Tergi River is Be...

Complaint > EPS Kolubara Environmental Improvement

Dispute Resolution: Problem-solving Completion Report Summary (English)

...requested that a Problem-solving Initiative (PSI) be undertaken by the PCM. In a written response to the first and the second Complaints, EBRD Management indicated support for a Problem-solving Initiative undertaken by the PCM. The Eligibility Assessment Report for a Problem-solving Initiative (PSI), released in August 2017, concluded that both Complaints are eligible and satisfy the criteria for a PSI in accordance with the PCM Rules of Procedure (PCM RP), specifically paragraphs 24-26 and 28-2...

Complaint > Ombla Hydro Power Plant

Monitoring: Monitoring report V

Ombla Hydropower Project REQUEST NUMBER: 2011/06 Compliance Review Monitoring Report V – November 2016 The Project Complaint Mechanism (PCM) is the independent accountability mechanism of the EBRD. PCM provides an opportunity for an independent review of complaints from one or more individual(s) or organisation(s) concerning an EBRD project, which allegedly has caused, or is likely to cause harm. PCM may address Complaints through two functions: Compliance Review, which seeks to determine whet...

Complaint > EPS Kolubara Environmental Improvement

Eligibility: Eligibility Assessment Report

...President, replacing Mr. Zeljko Stojkovic, who signed the Complaint as President of the Council at the time the Complaint was submitted to the PCM. Although the composition of the Council has changed since the elections, the issues raised in the Complaint are very similar to those presented to the Client by the current President of the Vreoci Council as noted in the minutes from two meetings attended by representatives from the Council, the Company and others. In a meeting held on 2 February, 20...

Complaint > GEORGIA - Jvari-Khorga Interconnection

Monitoring: Compliance Review Monitoring Report I

GEORGIA – Jvari-Khorga Interconnection Project REQUEST NUMBER: 2017/02 Compliance Review Monitoring Report I – December 2018 The Project Complaint Mechanism (PCM) is the independent accountability mechanism of the EBRD. PCM provides an opportunity for an independent review of complaints from one or more individual(s) or organisation(s) concerning an EBRD project, which allegedly has caused, or is likely to cause harm. PCM may address Complaints through two functions: Compliance Review, which s...

Complaint > Boskov Most Hydro Power

Monitoring: Monitoring report VI

Boskov Most Hydropower Project REQUEST NUMBER: 2011/05 Compliance Review Monitoring Report VI – March 2017 The Project Complaint Mechanism (PCM) is the independent accountability mechanism of the EBRD. PCM provides an opportunity for an independent review of complaints from one or more individual(s) or organisation(s) concerning an EBRD project, which allegedly has caused, or is likely to cause harm. PCM may address Complaints through two functions: Compliance Review, which seeks to determine ...

Complaint > Ombla Hydro Power Plant

Monitoring: Monitoring report IV

EUROPEAN BANK FOR RECONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT PROJECT COMPLAINT MECHANISM COMPLIANCE REVIEW MONITORING REPORT IV OMBLA HPP PROJECT, REQUEST NUMBER: 2011/06 March 2016 Compliance Review Monitoring Report Context This Compliance Review (CR) Monitoring Report is prepared pursuant to Rule 44 of the 2009 PCM Rules of Procedure (PCM RPs) 1 whereby, pursuant to a finding of non-compliance, the PCM Officer is mandated to monitor the implementation of the rec...

Complaint > EPS Emergency Power Sector Reconstruction Loan, EPS Power II and EPS Kolubara Environmental Improvement

Monitoring: Monitoring report II

EPS Emergency Power Sector Reconstruction Loan, EPS Power II and EPS Kolubara Environmental Improvement Projects REQUEST NUMBER: 2013/03 Compliance Review Monitoring Report II – February 2017 The Project Complaint Mechanism (PCM) is the independent accountability mechanism of the EBRD. PCM provides an opportunity for an independent review of complaints from one or more individual(s) or organisation(s) concerning an EBRD project, which allegedly has caused, or is likely to cause harm. PCM may a...

Complaint > Paravani Hydro Power Plant

Monitoring: Monitoring report V

...requested that the Bank Management discloses the flooding risk assessment and present it to all interested stakeholders. Besides that, the Complainant has requested that the Bank Management explains what mitigation measures are determined in the project in order to avoid eventual flooding in Khertvisi Village, besides the fact that the locals would be informed by Turkish authorities when such floods occur. Finally, the Complainant urges that the Bank insures the Client to disclose all materials ...

Complaint > Altain Khuder debt & equity

Monitoring: Compliance Review Monitoring Report I

...request that this item is closed. operations, EBRD’s monitoring and reporting requirements would be re-established and an assessment of current status against the ESAP commitments would need to be undertaken. Under such a development, EBRD would promptly request and implement monitoring events that would likely include a site visit, meetings with site personnel, and ...

Complaint > Agroinvestbank Equity Investment

Filing: Complaint

...requested then that information will not be supplied unless permission is given by the entity concerned, in this case AIB. Has such an approach been made by the EBRD to AIB and if so what was AIB’s response? If no approach was made, we would like to know why, and we would respectfully request that AIB be approached for permission to disclose the information and documentation requested. 11. Result Mr Schonberger hopes to achieve by submitting this complaint to the PCM Given the events t...

Complaint > Sostanj Thermal Power Plant

Compliance Report: Compliance Review Report

...Request No. 2011/05), para. 18; PCM, Compliance Review Report: Ombla Hydropower Project (Request No. 2011/06), para. 27. Indeed, the relevance of Article 6(3) of the 1992 Habitats Directive for the interpretation of Bank environmental safeguards can be traced back to Paragraphs 6 and 21 of the EBRD’s 2003 Environmental Policy, see PCM, Compliance Review Report: D1 Motorway, Phase 1, Slovak Republic (Request No. 2010/01), paras. 8-10 and 12. ...

Complaint > Dariali HPP

Monitoring: Compliance Review Monitoring Report I

DARIALI HPP PROJECT REQUEST NUMBER: 2014/05 Compliance Review Monitoring Report I – October 2017 The Project Complaint Mechanism (PCM) is the independent accountability mechanism of the EBRD. PCM provides an opportunity for an independent review of complaints from one or more individual(s) or organisation(s) concerning an EBRD project, which allegedly has caused, or is likely to cause harm. PCM may address Complaints through two functions: Compliance Review, which seeks to determine whether or...

Complaint > Paravani Hydro Power Plant

Monitoring: Monitoring report VI

Paravani Hydropower Project REQUEST NUMBER: 2012/01 Compliance Review Monitoring Report VI – March 2017 The Project Complaint Mechanism (PCM) is the independent accountability mechanism of the EBRD. PCM provides an opportunity for an independent review of complaints from one or more individual(s) or organisation(s) concerning an EBRD project, which allegedly has caused, or is likely to cause harm. PCM may address Complaints through two functions: Compliance Review, which seeks to determine whe...

Complaint > Dariali HPP

Eligibility: Eligibility Assessment Report

...President of Georgia, Mikheil Saakashvili, calling for suspension of large and other hydro-power development projects, including Dariali HPP, that pose a serious threat to the environment and livelihoods; December 21, 2011; See In Georgian: http://www.greenalt.org/webmill/data/file/Letter_to_president_HPP_geo.pdf In English: http://www.greenalt.org/webmill/data/file/Letter_to_president_HPPs_ENG.pdf 5. Green Alternative issued and disseminated the fact sheet “How Tergi River is Be...

Complaint > Boskov Most Hydro Power

Monitoring: Monitoring report V

Boskov Most Hydropower Project REQUEST NUMBER: 2011/05 Compliance Review Monitoring Report V – November 2016 The Project Complaint Mechanism (PCM) is the independent accountability mechanism of the EBRD. PCM provides an opportunity for an independent review of complaints from one or more individual(s) or organisation(s) concerning an EBRD project, which allegedly has caused, or is likely to cause harm. PCM may address Complaints through two functions: Compliance Review, which seeks to determin...

Complaint > Tbilisi Railway Bypass 3

Eligibility: Eligibility Assessment Report

...requests both a Problem-solving Initiative and a Compliance Review. The Compliance Review request relates to economic displacement, and alleges a breach of Performance Requirement 5 of the EBRD Environmental and Social Policy 2008, paras. 31 and 32. As these Compliance Review aspects correspond closely with, though do not overlap precisely with, the aspects of the Compliance Review requested under the Tbilisi Railway Bypass 1 Complaint, it makes sense in terms of procedural efficiency and c...

Complaint > EPS Kolubara Environmental Improvement

Filing: Complaint

...President of Managing Board President of the Council Gordana Kulić Željko Stojković Sources and literature [1] http://www.lazarevac.rs [2] http://mzvreoci.org.rs [3] Law on local self-government (Official Herald of the Republic of Serbia No. 129/07) [4] http://www.eps.rs/ [5] http://www.rbkolubara.rs/ [6] Decision on acceptance of the Programm...