Complaint > South-West Corridor Road Project

Monitoring: Problem-solving Initiative Monitoring Report II

...requested that both a Problem-solving Initiative (PSI) and a Compliance Review (CR) be undertaken by the PCM. The Eligibility Assessment Report for a Problem-solving Initiative, released in September 2015, concluded that the Complaint was eligible under the PCM’s Rules of Procedure (PCM RPs). On 20 October 2015, the President of the Bank accepted the recommendation of the Eligibility Assessors for a PSI and PCM Expert Susan Wildau was appointed to undertake the assignment. The PCM Expert conduct...

Complaint > South-West Corridor Road Project

Monitoring: Problem-solving Initiative Monitoring Report I

...requested both a Problem-solving Initiative and a Compliance Review. The Eligibility Assessment Report for a Problem-solving Initiative (PSI), released in September 2015, concluded that the Complaint was eligible under the PCM’s Rules of Procedure (PCM RPs). On 20 October 2015, the President of the Bank accepted the recommendation of the Eligibility Assessors for a PSI and PCM Expert Susan Wildau was appointed to undertake the assignment. The PCM Expert conducted the PSI, including in-country me...

Complaint > EPS Kolubara Environmental Improvement

Monitoring: Problem-solving Initiative Monitoring Report I (English)

...requested that PCM undertake problem-solving to address the concerns raised. The Eligibility Assessment Report relating to the Complaints, released in August 2017, found both Complaints eligible for a Problem-solving Initiative (PSI) in accordance with the PCM Rules of Procedure (PCM RP).The President of the EBRD accepted the recommendation of the Eligibility Assessors to proceed with PSI, and on 1 September 2017 PCM Expert Constantin-Adi Gavrilă initiated the PSI. Given the need for culturally ...

Complaint > Tbilisi Railway Bypass 3

Timeline: Processing steps

...President for approval, pursuant PCM RP 29(b) 10. Problem-solving 22 September Initiative approved by the 2011 President 11. Eligibility Assessment 23 September Report is publicly released 2011 and posted on the website The Eligibility Assessors recommended one joint PSI to address issues raised in the Complaints 2, 3 and 4 ...

Complaint > Tbilisi Railway Bypass 2

Timeline: Processing steps

...President for approval pursuant PCM, RP 29(b) 10. Problem-solving 22 September Initiative approved by the 2011 President 11. Eligibility Assessment 23 September Report is publicly released 2011 and posted on the website The Eligibility Assessors recommended one joint PSI to address issues raised in the Complaints 2, 3 and 4 on Tbilisi...

Complaint > Tbilisi Railway Bypass 1

Timeline: Processing steps

...President and the Board pursuant PCM, RP 29 10. Eligibility Assessment Report 19 September 2011 is publicly released and posted on the PCM website pursuant PCM, RP 29 (a) 11. According to the PCM RP 50, 4 November 2011 the Board of Directors approved, based on the recommendation of the President, the ad hoc appointment of Dr Daniel Bradlow as a Compliance Review Expert for the Complaint. 12. The deadline for the 31 May 2012 Compliance Review Report is extended...

Complaint > EPS Kolubara Environmental Improvement

Monitoring: Problem-solving Initiative Monitoring Report III (English)

...requested that PCM undertake a PSI to assist in resolving the issues identified. In August 2017, the PCM found both Complaints eligible for a single PSI. 2 The EBRD President accepted the Eligibility Assessors’ recommendation to initiate a PSI and in September 2017, Constantin-Adi Gavrilă was appointed to lead the Initiative as PCM Expert under the PCM Rules of Procedure (RP). Given the need for culturally-appropriate mediation between the Complainants and the Client (i.e., “the Parties”), PCM a...

Complaint > DIF Lydian (Amulsar Gold Mine) 2

Timeline: Processing steps

...President with the recommendation that the Complaints be closed. 5. President approved the recommendation to close the 4 February 2015 Complaints, pursuant to PCM RP27. 6. The Eligibility Assessment Report and the decision was 12 February 2015 sent to the Relevant Parties and publicly disclosed.

Complaint > DIF Lydian (Amulsar Gold Mine)

Timeline: Processing steps

...President with the recommendation that the Complaints be closed. 5. President approved PCM Recommendation to close the 4 February 2015 Complaints pursuant to PCM, RP27. 6. The Eligibility Assessment Report and the decision was 12 February 2015 sent to the Relevant Parties and publicly disclosed.

Complaint > Rivne Kyiv High Voltage Line

Timeline: Processing steps

...President and the Board of Directors pursuant PCM RP 29. 6. Compliance Review Expert 12 November 2012 Ad hoc Expert Prof Geert Van appointed. Calster 7. Eligibility Assessment 12 November 2012 Report is publicly released and posted on the PCM website pursuant PCM RP 29(a). 8. Compliance Review Report 3 September 2013 sent to Relevant Parties, including the President and the Board of Directors for information pursuant PCM RP ...

Complaint > EPS Kolubara Environmental Improvement

Monitoring: Problem-solving Initiative Monitoring Report II (English)

...requested that PCM undertake problem-solving to address the concerns raised. The Eligibility Assessment Report relating to the Complaints, released in August 2017, found both Complaints eligible for a single Problem-solving Initiative, in accordance with the PCM Rules of Procedure (PCM RP).The President of the EBRD accepted the recommendation of the Eligibility Assessors to initiate the PSI, and on 1 September 2017, PCM Expert Constantin-Adi Gavrilă initiated the PSI. Given the need for cultural...

Complaint > Belgrade Public Transport and Traffic Infrastructure

Timeline: Processing steps

...President and the Board of Directors pursuant to PCM RP 33. 6. Eligibility Assessment 6 November 2017 Report and President’s decision for the Problem- solving Initiative are publicly released and posted on the PCM website pursuant to PCM RP 33(b). 7. Ad hoc PCM Expert Adi 6 November 2017 Gavrila is assigned as the Problem-solving Expert for the Complaints (2017/06 and 2017/08).

Complaint > EPS Kolubara Environmental Improvement

Timeline: Processing steps

...President and the Board of Directors pursuant to PCM RP 33. 7. Eligibility Assessment 11 August 2017 Report and President’s decision for the Problem- solving Initiative are publicly released and posted on the PCM website pursuant to PCM RP 33(b). 8. Ad hoc PCM Expert Adi 14 August 2017 It is intended that the first Gavrila is assigned as the stage of the process, Problem-solving Expert for the including capacity-bui...

Complaint > EPS Kolubara Environmental Improvement

Timeline: Processing steps

...President and the Board of Directors pursuant PCM RP 29. 5. Eligibility Assessment 9 August 2013 Report is publicly released and posted on the PCM website pursuant PCM RP 29(a). 6. According to the PCM RP 9 September 2013 50, the Board of Directors approved, based on the recommendation of the President, the ad hoc appointment of Mr Glen Armstrong as a Compliance Review Expert for the Complaint. 7. In the interests of 10 March 2014 procedural and administrative effici...

Complaint > Sostanj Thermal Power Plant

Timeline: Processing steps

...President and the Board of Directors pursuant PCM RP 29. 7. Compliance Review Expert 15 January 2013 Dr Owen McIntyre appointed. 8. Eligibility Assessment 22 January 2013 Report is publicly released and posted on the PCM website pursuant PCM RP 29 (a). 9. Compliance Review Report 17 September 2013 sent to Relevant Parties, including the President and the Board of Directors for information pursuant PCM RP 39. 10. Compliance Review Report 23 September 2013 is pos...

Complaint > Paravani Hydro Power Plant

Timeline: Processing steps

...President and the Board of Directors pursuant PCM RP 29. 7. According to the PCM RP 50, the Board of Directors approved, based 23 October 2012 on the recommendation of the President, the ad hoc appointment of Mr Glen Armstrong as a Compliance Review Expert for the Complaint. 8. Eligibility Assessment Report is publicly released and posted on the 24 October 2012 PCM website pursuant PCM RP 29(a). 9. Draft Compliance Review report 13 June 2013 is sent to Bank Management for the develop...

Complaint > Tbilisi Railway Bypass 4

Timeline: Processing steps

...President for approval pursuant PCM, RP 29(b). 10. Problem-solving 22 September Initiative approved by the 2011 President. 11. Eligibility Assessment 23 September Report is publicly released 2011 and posted on the website. The Eligibility Assessors recommended one joint PSI to address issues raised in the Complaints 2,...

Complaint > South-West Corridor Road Project

Timeline: Processing steps

Updated: 5 December 2016 European Bank for Reconstruction and Development Project Complaint Mechanism Request number: 2014/04 Project name: South-West Corridor Road Project Project number: 39258 Country: Kazakhstan Step Date Remarks 1. Signed Complaint received Complaint is received in by PCM Officer. 20 October 2014 Russian and sent for ...

Complaint > EPS Kolubara Environmental Improvement

Eligibility: Eligibility Assessment Report for PSI (English)

...requested that a Problem-solving Initiative (PSI) be undertaken by the PCM. The Eligibility Assessors have determined that both Complaints are eligible for a PSI in accordance with the PCM Rules of Procedure (PCM RP), specifically paragraphs 24-26 and 28- 29. The Complaint: • has been filed within prescribed timeframes; • describes the PCM functions requested; • describes the outcomes sought; • provides adequate information relating to communications with the Bank and...

Complaint > EPS Power II

Timeline: Processing steps

...Request number: 2013/02 Project name: EPS Power II Project number: 27005 Country: Serbia Step Date Remarks 1. The unsigned complaint is 12 August 2013 PCM Officer requested a received by the PCM Officer. signed copy of the complaint. 2. The signed complaint is 16 August 2013 Electronic scanned copy received. received by email. 3. C...