Complaint > Mumbai Urban Transport Project

Management Action Plan: 32-Sixth Management Progress Report

...cash compensation for the land they had lost; they the social and economic needs of the affected people, could utilize these to build properties elsewhere. the drawing up of resettlement action plans, and Private interest in resettlement increased as the the establishment of mechanisms and capacity for developers learnt to convert TDR/FSI into profitable implementation. The government did all that was investments in the Mumb...

Complaint > Reventazon Hydroelectric Power Project

Management Response: Management Response

...cash compensation at full replacement cost following laws and regulations applicable in Costa Rica. The criteria for land valuation are also detailed in the Marco Estrategico. The land expropriation process and related compensation are currently under judicial review in Costa Rica. 4.4.3 It is also worth noting that as part of the implementation of the Project, ICE has acquired approximately 1,900 hectares extending to 137 properties. These processes e...

Complaint > Petroleum Development and Pipeline Project, Management of the Petroleum Economy Project, and Petroleum Sector Management Capacity Building Project

Project Document: Chad-Cameroon Petroleum Development and Pipeline Project Program Performance and Assessment Report

...compensation programs in both countries. Villages received community compensation, such as water wells and water points, electrification, community centers, schools, etc. Individuals were compensated for lost land, trees, and other types o f property. In Cameroon, the COTCO-PSMC-NGO platform for cooperation and grievance resolution began operations to ensure that compensation programs were delivered as intended. During the construction phase, COTCO implemented a compensation program for in...

Complaint > Lukoil Overseas-01/Berezovka

Eligibility: English

...cash compensation. The CAO was unable to ascertain what proportion of the village seeks resettlement. CAO Findings The Complainants see the Tungush resettlement as a precedent and expect KPO to take responsibility for the fact that they have not been resettled (see Appendix 5 for resettlement timeline). There was no technical requirement for the Tangush resettlement as a result of the project’s activities but KPO has become implicated as a result of a request to implement a resettlement p...

Complaint > Third Power Project, Fourth Power Project, and proposed Bujagali Hydropower Project

Other: 24-Annexes to Management Report and Recommendation

...Compensation for Tourism: In failing to ensure 8.6, OD Comment: Loss of tourism income and employment was dealt that compensation was paid, and/or rehabilitation 301- 4.30 with in two ways: (1) at the level of the tourism enterprises or op- was provided, to people who will lose their primary 307 erators; and (2) at the level of project-affected individuals deriving sources of income as a result of the Project’s im- income from to...

Complaint > Proposed Kosovo Power Project and Second Additional Financing Energy Sector Clean-up and Land Reclamation Project

Compliance Report: 103-Inspection Panel Investigation Report(English)

...compensation options, processes, and procedures. It recommended providing clearer compensation options, making more effort to collect information about the affected households and better informing them about compensation options through a public information campaign, and undertaking a transparent consultation process. 131 In June 2005 a pre-identification mission for another Bank project undertook preliminary evaluation of Kosovo’s resettlement practices in relation to the Bank’s Involunta...

Complaint > GCF-EBRD Egypt Renewable Energy Financing Framework

Compliance Review: Compliance Appraisal Report 02

...compensation, and benefits upon beginning the working relationship and when any material changes occur.88 The complainant asserts that on a number of occasions there were material changes in his role, including a verbal agreement to pay an additional monthly sum. He says that no changes were made to his written contract to reflect these changes. The IRM notes that in principle PS 2 would require a material change in the compensation of a worker who fell within its scope to be included in do...

Complaint > Integrated Coastal Zone Management and Clean-Up Project, First Request

Compliance Report: 47-Investigation Report (English)

...cash, and/or employment) if they occupy the project area prior to a cut-off date, established by the borrower and acceptable to the Bank. Only persons who “encroach on the area after the cut-off date are not entitled to compensation or any other form of resettlement assistance.” (b) Management Decision Not to Apply the Policy to Ongoing Demolitions in the Project Area In explaining Management’s decision not to apply OP/BP 4.12 for demolitions in the Project area, the PAD states tha...

Complaint > Transport Sector Development Project - Additional Financing

Management Action Plan: Lessons Learned and Agenda for Action

...compensation to all affected people in the right of way; the fact that affected people living within a 500-meter safety radius had not been relocated; the operation of quarries with disregard for basic standards of health and safety; and the indiscriminate destruction of personal property along the road. In addition, UNRA had yet to set up a grievance redress mechanism (GRM) on compensation. As a consequence, the social (and environmental) safeguard rating, rated moderately unsatisfactory (...

Complaint > Second National Water Development Project - AdditionalFinancing

Filing: 86-Request for Inspection (English)

...cash   for   credits   on   the   meter   can   be   scarce   at   times.   A   regular   credit   meter   would   allow   the   essential   service   to   continue   for   a   period   in   credit   mode,   whereas   a   cash   poor   individual   would   have   to   suffer  without  water  with  a  prepaid  meter.  The  consequences  can  be  particula...

Complaint > EPS Restructuring

Compliance Report: Compliance Review Report

...compensation, recruitment, nominations, planning and procurement. The loan proceeds will be used to restructure EPS’s balance sheet, replacing short and medium term financial debt incurred to alleviate a critical cash situation created by the unprecedented and catastrophic floods in Serbia in 2014. For the purpose of this Compliance Review Report, the restructuring plan will be referred to as “the EPS Restructuring Project” or the “Project”. According to the Bank Management response, “the refina...

Complaint > PT Weda Bay Nickel-01/Weda Bay

Eligibility: Ombudsman Assessment Report: Complaint Regarding the MIGA PT Weda Bay Nickel Project (#8113), Halmahera Island, North Maluku, Indonesia, June 2011

...cash compensation where appropriate; and (ii) provide relocation assistance suited to the needs of each group of displaced persons, with particular attention paid to the needs of the poor and the vulnerable. However what we found was:  The presence of the Tobelo Forest people who live in the region or area of the Contract of Work conflicts with the statement that “it is hoped that there will be no physical dispossession of families from their homes” (V-1) and the ...

Complaint > Barro Blanco

Compliance Report: Panel report No. 1 Barro Blanco Hydroelectric Project Panama

...compensation and due process available to those with full legal title to land in the case of commercial development of their land under national laws, together with culturally appropriate development opportunities; land-based compensation or compensation-in-kind will be offered in lieu of cash compensation where feasible  The client will enter into good faith negotiation with the affected communities of Indigenous Peoples, and document their informed participation and the successful outcom...

Complaint > Energy Resources Phase II & Oyu Tolgoi

Compliance Report: Compliance Review Report (OT)

...Compensation and Mitigation Measures, including alleged failures regarding: a. Alternative project design to avoid or minimise physical and/or economic displacement; b. Inadequate compensation framework; and c. Updated compensation framework. 3. Issues related to PR 7: Indigenous Peoples; 4. Issues related to PR 8: Cultural Heritage; and 5. Issues related to PR 10: Information Dis...

Complaint > Lagos Metropolitan Development and Governance Project

Registration: 91-Annexes to the Notice of Non-Registration - Request for Inspection, Management Action Plan, related documents (English)

...cash compensation is all that is offered, the government needs to ensure that affected people are provided with appropriate sustainable livelihood assistance, such as skills training, micro-credit, and employment opportunities.”165 It is essential that people who are unable to provide for themselves are offered adequate alternative housing. The UN Basic Principles provide that “[c]ash compensation should under no circumstances replace real compensation in the form of land and common proper...

Complaint > Nenskra Hydropower Project

Compliance Review: Report of ADB's Board Compliance Review Committee and CRP's Report on Eligibility (English)

...compensation for loss of income but not for loss of land. The project affected persons are considered displaced persons without recognizable claims to such land. [See SPS, Appendix 2, para. 7 (iii)]. 61. The ESIA provides that all households affected by loss of pastures will receive fodder in compensation (either in cash or kind) during a period of seven years as construction activities are planned for 5 years and two additional years are planned for reconstruction of pasture areas. S...

Complaint > Nenskra Hydropower Project

Eligibility: CRP Eligibility Report (English)

...compensation for loss of income but not for loss of land. The project affected persons are considered displaced persons without recognizable claims to such land. [See SPS, Appendix 2, para. 7 (iii)]. 61. The ESIA provides that all households affected by loss of pastures will receive fodder in compensation (either in cash or kind) during a period of seven years as construction activities are planned for 5 years and two additional years are planned for reconstruction of pasture areas. S...

Complaint > DRC High Priority Roads Reopening and Maintenance (2nd Additional Financing)

Compliance Report: Inspection Panel Investigation Report(English)

...compensation of USD100 for each transporter for the time they were unable to work. The compensation was based on the number of deliveries and estimated distance each transporter could normally complete.210 During a meeting on January 16, 2018, when the Contractor paid the total compensation, the parties agreed to raise the number of covered transporters to 68.211 As for the cooperative extracting the sand, the Supervising Engineer assessed the appropriate compensation to be USD13,500 based on th...

Complaint > La Paz Storm Drainage Program II

Compliance Report: Distribution of Panel Report to the Board of Executive Directors

...compensation or offsets should be implemented. Generally speaking, the documents reviewed envisaged that both the program and the work would have a markedly positive environmental and social impact, since they would -4- improve living conditions by preventing flooding and emergencies and reducing property damage and apprehension about disasters in at-risk areas. However, it was also thought that the works could cause local adverse impacts of low to...

Complaint > Petroleum Development and Pipeline Project, Management of the Petroleum Economy Project, and Petroleum Sector Management Capacity Building Project

Eligibility: 22-Management Report and Recommendation (English)

...compensation for, lost assets including land tenure issues. 25. General Issues of 17.3, 4.30 Comment: Management acknowledges the finding of compliance to Compensation. In the Panel’s 175- date. view the compensation and 178; 183; implementation processes were Action: Management is committed to continued monitoring of the overall ...