Downtown Redevelopment, Modernization of Metropolitan Public Transport, and of Government Offices Project | Accountability Console
Complaints IAMs Register Login

Complaints

Visualize Complaint List Complaint Map Document Search

Accountability

Snapshot of IAMs Compare IAM Policies

Newsletter

Newsletters Article Archive Ask A Question

Support

FAQ Alerts Glossary User Guides Contact Us Donate

Loading...

Downtown Redevelopment, Modernization of Metropolitan Public Transport, and of Government Offices Project

Issues

Consultation and disclosure

Description: Complaint raises concerns regarding inadequate or absent consultation about or disclosure of project information, including project impacts and/or mitigation plans.

Complaints with this Issue: 522

Browse Complaints

Cultural heritage

Description: Complaint raises concerns about impacts on any type of tangible or intangible cultural heritage, including significant sites, unique environmental features, cultural knowledge, and traditional lifestyles.

Complaints with this Issue: 117

Browse Complaints

Displacement (physical and/or economic)

Description: Complaint raises concerns about physical relocation, loss of shelter, and/or loss of assets that relate to income or livelihood.

Complaints with this Issue: 470

Browse Complaints

Due diligence

Description: Complaint raises concerns about inadequate or absent prior investigation of project impacts.

Complaints with this Issue: 476

Browse Complaints

Environmental

Description: Complaint raises concerns regarding environmental impacts that do not refer specifically to water, pollution, or biodiversity.

Complaints with this Issue: 382

Browse Complaints

Livelihoods

Description: Complaint raises concerns about impacts on the means by which people make a living, including wage-based income, trade and bartering, agriculture, fishing, foraging, and other natural-resource based means.

Complaints with this Issue: 337

Browse Complaints

Sectors

Infrastructure

Description: Project relates to construction or improvement of large structures, facilities, or public works projects. Examples include roads and other transportation projects, sanitation and water treatment facilities, power plants, and industrial facilities.

Complaints in this Sector: 944

Browse Complaints

Complaint

IAM: Independent Consultation and Investigation Mechanism (MICI)

ID: MICI-BID-PR-2016-0101

Date Filed: May 17, 2016

Date Closed: May 27, 2021

Status: Closed With Outputs

Description

The 11 Requesters are merchants whose businesses are located at "Mercado 4" and around the  Eusebio Ayala Street at Asunción city center, where the IDB is financing a Metrobus system.They allege that they were not consulted on the project, and for those that will need to leave the are, no alternative location nor compensation has been offered. They also comment that there are no environmental and cultural heritage impact studies.As regards the alleged harm, they comment that the project will have a negative impact on their livelihoods in two aspects: the first, during execution, as they consider that sales will drop due to lack of access and that will in turn reduce their profits, lead them to fire personnel with the ensuing impact on family incomes; the second, comes from those that have been informed they have to leave the area and relocate somewhere else without any relocation plans or compensation.This Request is linked to numberMICI-PR-2016-0099, which provides complementary information.The Request includes testimonial videos available only in Spanish.

Complaint Stages

Filing

May 17, 2016

Filing

Status:

Start Date: May 17, 2016

Registration

May 17, 2016 -

May 25, 2016

Registration

Status: Closed With Output

Start Date: May 17, 2016

End Date: May 25, 2016

Eligibility

May 25, 2016 -

Aug. 5, 2016

Eligibility

Status: Closed With Output

Start Date: May 25, 2016

End Date: Aug. 5, 2016

Dispute Resolution

Not Undertaken

Dispute Resolution

Status: Not Undertaken

Explanation: Not desired by complainant

Compliance Review

Jan. 25, 2017 -

Dec. 10, 2018

Compliance Review

Status: Closed With Output

Start Date: Jan. 25, 2017

End Date: Dec. 10, 2018

Has Compliance Report: Yes

Non-Compliance Found: Yes

Monitoring

Dec. 10, 2018 -

May 27, 2021

Monitoring

Status: Closed With Output

Start Date: Dec. 10, 2018

End Date: May 27, 2021

Closed

May 27, 2021

Timeline

Documents

Name Category Description
Request Receipt Filing
Request Receipt Filing
Request Receipt Filing
Request Receipt Filing
Request Receipt Filing
Request Receipt Filing
Request Receipt Filing
Request Receipt Filing
Request Receipt Filing
Request Receipt Filing
Notice of Registration Registration document.cfm?id=40325892.pdf
Management Response Management Response document.cfm?id=40387460.pdf
Eligibility Memorandum Public Disclosure Eligibility document.cfm?id=40433796.pdf
Assessment Report Public Disclosure Appraisal document.cfm?id=40711558.pdf
Transfer to Compliance Review Phase Compliance Review document.cfm?id=40719763.pdf
Consideration by the Board of Executive Directors of the Recommendation and ToRs Management Response document.cfm?id=40830922.pdf
Expected completion date of Investigation / Issuance of Draft Compliance Review Report Timeline document.cfm?id=EZSHARE-33351106-738.pdf
Expected completion date of Investigation / Issuance of Draft Compliance Review Report Timeline document.cfm?id=EZSHARE-33351106-1287.pdf
Expected completion date of Investigation / Issuance of Draft Compliance Review Report Timeline document.cfm?id=EZSHARE-33351106-793.pdf
Distribution of the Compliance Review Report for consideration by the Board of Executive Directors Compliance Review document.cfm?id=EZSHARE-33351106-1397.pdf
Public Release of the Compliance Review Report and final decision by the Board of Executive Directors Compliance Review document.cfm?id=EZSHARE-33351106-1403.pdf
Public Release of the Compliance Review Report and final decision by the Board of Executive Directors Compliance Review document.cfm?id=EZSHARE-33351106-1402.pdf
Closure Report Closing Report
Management Action Plan Management Action Plan

Commitments

Type Category Description Status
Cash Compensation Supplementary Compensation Plan Cancelled
Cultural Heritage Cultural Heritage Historical Cultural Heritage Protection Plan Cancelled
Information disclosure Consultation Disclosure of Project Documentation Cancelled
Monitoring Remedies Monitoring Preparation and Execution of MAP Cancelled
Monitoring Remedies Monitoring Monitor Cultural Heritage Protection Plan Cancelled
Monitoring Remedies Monitoring Monitor MAP Cancelled
Other Livelihoods Livelihoods Livelihood Corrective Measures Cancelled
Other Livelihoods Livelihoods Livelihood Corrective Measures Cancelled
Policy Change Operations Management E&S Policy Cancelled
Policy Change Operations Management Environmental and Social Policy Accomplished
Studies (not environmental) Consultation Evaluation of Livelihood Cancelled
Studies (not environmental) Consultation Livelihood Assessment Cancelled

Related Complaints

Project IAM Country Date Filed Status
Downtown Redevelopment, Modernization Metropolitan Public Transport and Government Offices IDB MICI Paraguay 11/03/2016 Closed Without Outputs
Downtown Redevelopment, Modernization of Metropolitan Public Transport, and of Government Offices Project — Request III IDB MICI Paraguay 25/04/2023 Closed With Outputs
By Accountability Counsel Contact About Privacy Policy Terms of Use

©2024 All Rights Reserved