Complaint > Integrated Citarum Water Resources Management Investment Program 2

Dispute Resolution: Comments on the RAR: Operations Department

...compensation for state land users or people utilizing state land. While referring to the Presidential Regulations on Land Acquisition, there are several kinds of compensation offered to the entitled people including cash compensation. In 2008, the Local Government of Bekasi District issued the Decree on cash compensation for illegal settlers. This statement needs also to be corrected as RP states that the compensation for APs' losses will be provided both in cash and in-kind (particular...

Complaint > Integrated Citarum Water Resources Management Investment Program 2

Dispute Resolution: Review and Assessment Report (English)

...Compensation for APs in Bekasi District. The complainants have requested cash compensation as soon as possible to improve their living conditions. They explained that after the evictions their living conditions worsened. According to the laws and regulations of the Government of Indonesia it is not possible to provide cash compensation to APs. It would be possible, however, to use the livelihood restoration program as agreed upon in the resettlement plan 2008 to provide noncash compensation...

Complaint > Integrated Citarum Water Resources Management Investment Program 2

Dispute Resolution: Final Report (English)

...compensation for affected persons (APs); (ii) updating and implementation of the Resettlement Plan 2008; (iii) communication, resettlement-related information, and consultations; and (iv) government laws and regulations, and the ADB Policy on Involuntary Resettlement (1995). The complainants have requested cash compensation as soon as possible to improve their living conditions. The RAR found that the complainants are not familiar with the planned resettlement activities, with the Governmen...

Complaint > MFF Sustainable Urban Transport Investment Program - Tranche 3

Dispute Resolution: Summary of the Review and Assessment Report (English)

...Compensation for the two-story building apartments 6. The compensation strategy for the two-story building owners will follow self-relocation principles and is based on cash compensation at replacement cost. The building consists of discrete properties and is inhabited by 40 households in 42 apartments. As a former dormitory, apartments are typically small. A detailed measurement survey was carried out in 2013, with pricing for materials based on market rates at that time. Due to the sizes ...

Complaint > Ulaanbaatar Urban Services and Ger Areas Development Investment Program - Tranche 2

Dispute Resolution: Review and Assessment Report - English

...compensation 14. Complainants asserted that they negotiated compensation packages for land and property during July-August in 2020 and expected to receive compensation payments in the fall of the same year, so that they could resettle before the succeeding winter. Some complainants packed belongings ready to move. The compensation has not been paid and due to the uncertainty as to precisely when it will be paid, the complainants have been unable to plan their lives. Subsequent 4 to the PM...

Complaint > Ulaanbaatar Urban Services and Ger Areas Development Investment Program - Tranche 2

Dispute Resolution: Final Report-English

...Compensation Increase by Complainant 15. Second, the Mayor’s Ordinance #A/526 on transferring responsibilities for payment of resettlement compensation to APs from the MUB to the Ulaanbaatar Urban Services and Ger Areas Development Investment Program (or GADIP) PMO was issued on 30 June 2021. This ordinance aims to (i) ensure sufficient fund allocation for financing the resettlement compensation payments in line with ADB and national requirements, and (ii) expedite compensation payments to...

Complaint > Punjab Intermediate Cities Improvement Investment Project

Dispute Resolution: Review and Assessment & Problem-Solving Report (English)

...compensation of the project GRM were successfully resolved and the affected households received their compensation payments. The unresolved complaint was from a group of 18 households who refused to accept the enhanced compensation offer based on the additional IVS study and subsequently reached out to OSPF. 20. The 18 households explained that the compensation amount determined was insufficient to purchase land of similar quality and size in the same locality. In addition, the complainant...

Complaint > Punjab Intermediate Cities Improvement Investment Project

Dispute Resolution: Review and Assessment & Problem-Solving Report (English)

...compensation of the project GRM were successfully resolved and the affected households received their compensation payments. The unresolved complaint was from a group of 18 households who refused to accept the enhanced compensation offer based on the additional IVS study and subsequently reached out to OSPF. 20. The 18 households explained that the compensation amount determined was insufficient to purchase land of similar quality and size in the same locality. In addition, the complainant...

Complaint > BTC Pipeline-20/Atskuri

Dispute Resolution: Problem Solving Completion Report

...Cash compensation for standing crop, regardless of the stage in their growth cycle Cash compensation for lost crops on orphaned land decided on a case by case basis Return land for use, with restrictions, post construction Replace or compensate at full replacement value all non-movable assets (sheds etc) Private land/ 58 meters (use restrictions) Cash compensation where the landowner can demonstrate that the restriction imposes a loss Table 1 Compensation for Private Land reprodu...

Complaint > Productive Infrastructure Program - Request II: Caracol Industrial Park (MICI)

Dispute Resolution: Consultation Phase Report Public Disclosure

...compensation payments were not commensurate with the losses they incurred as a result of their displacement. They point out that the provision of cash compensation was not sustainable and did not enable them to restore their livelihoods. In particular, they assert that the compensation failed to take account of the increased cost of living stemming from the PIC’s location in the area and the value of the investments made in the land they had been f...

Complaint > National Highway Development Sector Investment Program

Dispute Resolution: Review and Assessment report (RAR)

...cash compensation and rehabilitation assistance, irrespective of their land ownership status, to ensure that those affected by the Project shall be at least as well off, if not better off, than they would have been without the Project; (iii) The compensation packages shall reflect replacement costs for all losses (such as land, crops, trees, structures, businesses, incomes, etc.); (iv) Compensation and resettlement will be satisfactorily completed before a NoObjection Certificate can be pr...

Complaint > Low-Income Neighborhood Improvement Program - Habitar Brasil

Dispute Resolution: Issuance of Consultation Phase Report

...compensation for the furniture. 6. In July 2013, the Mayor, Mr. Carlinhos Almeida, notified the Requesters that he was waiting for the legal report on the legal status of the compensation for the furniture to be able to make a decision. 7. In October 2013, following prior consultation and a favorable opinion issued by the Secretary of Legal Affairs on the possibility of formalizing an agreement, the Mayor announced his intention to pay the compensation in full, but that for budgetary reas...

Complaint > Southern Punjab Basic Urban Services Project

Dispute Resolution: Review and Assessment Report (RAR) (English)

...Compensation, and Livelihood 29. Land Acquisition and Compensation. Land acquisition is done according to the Land Acquisition Act of Pakistan, which has provisions for grievance redress that both BoR and the SPBUSP must follow. The initial compensation rate awarded to APs was PRs500,000 per acre of land. Everyone agreed that this assessment did not reflect market rates and "was on the low side." Upon request from the APs, the government made a reassessment. The District Price Assessment C...

Complaint > Melamchi Water Supply Project (MWSP)

Dispute Resolution: Final Report, 22 Dec 2004

...compensation and resettlement The land acquisition, compensation and resettlement process and related activities have been grossly arbitrary. There was and still is the lack of minimum standards to be made applicable to all the affected persons and the families when making decisions about who to displace, how and where. The displaced families have not been given adequate time to move and resettle and there has been no reasonable offer for resettlement. The payment of cash compensation in a...

Complaint > Melamchi Water Supply Project (MWSP)

Dispute Resolution: Review and Assessment Report, 25 Jun 2004

...compensation and resettlement The land acquisition, compensation and resettlement process and related activities have been grossly arbitrary. There was and still is the lack of minimum standards to be made applicable to all the affected persons and the families when making decisions about who to displace, how and where. The displaced families have not been given adequate time to move and resettle and there has been no reasonable offer for resettlement. The payment of cash compensation in a...